I vaguely remember picking this book up in middle school or something, but didn’t pay it much thought. Halfway through the book, I realized I’ve read this book once before…surprise?
I think this was a cute and charming novel. It feels almost like “Howl’s Moving Castle” for a tar younger audience. I don’t know my initial thoughts of it, but I think I found this book neat with an interesting story that develops page by page. It’s not too serious, while still the threat of being burned at the stake if found out, it creates a tension. I found it amusing to read as an adult, while it being meant for children and it makes me want to read more of this series.
However, I think the level of fear was different in an unlikely way. The law of the book’s world is so that everyone who possess witchcraft and/or use it in any way will be killed, preferably burned. This made society very wary of witches and wizard, and no-one wants to be accused of being one as it is likely to be sentenced to death. Because of this, I find the main character’s, children that is, range of very odd. While some slept with the fear of being brought to the inquisitor, others just played around and practically announced that they were witches. They didn’t even try to be careful.
At times I found the tension curve a bit odd. It spiked and dipped as it pleased. Nothing big though.
I really liked how the author tied everything together at the end, with the “Simon says” as a final conclusion. It was quite clever of her to turn the curse around and make it work to their advantage. Every event added together and crafted a red thread that lasted through the book. Also, I like how she linked the ending and opening sequences. It was a nice way of showing the change of character.